about office hours

sign in to office hours

Office HoursFall 2026

You Can See Everything

Discussion Guide

A still from You Can See Everything
still: A24

Discussing: You Can See Everything, dir. Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim (2026)

Meets: Tuesday, November 17, 6–8pm, Rabbit Books & Bar, 170 Avenue A.

Host: Andrew Nadkarni (@andrewnadkarni).

Topics

  1. A character I created.. or they created

    Who gets to define Elizabeth Holmes? see more →

1

The readings and questions, online:
officehoursny.com/you-can-see-everything

topic 1 of 8

A character I created.. or they created

“Who gets to define Elizabeth Holmes?”
— @andrewnadkarnihost

I'm also interested in whether it is possible to voluntarily let go of our right to define ourself. It seems like this is Elizabeth's way of being... or "strategy"?

@reilly.timhost

On this quote, her inability to understand the "Who's On First?" bit, her lack of understanding the wording of her own marketing of Theranos, these contradict her and her husband's fixation on the NYT article. What do we think of this?

anonymous

“The David Blaine anecdote seems to play a critical role in the film's meaning – is his "character" as a magician created by him or us?”
— @reilly.timhost

sign in to follow your question

topic 2 of 8

Sympathy, empathy & accountability

“Does the film risk coloring EH in a favorable light? Does it sufficiently deal with her risking the health of thousands of people for personal gain?”
— @annalee.taihost

This is my biggest criticism of the film! EH is guilty (which was proven beyond a reasonable doubt) and she did hurt patients. She showed absolutely zero remorse and the movie does not acknowledge the victims of EH

anonymous

agree, Nathan and Lance chose not to dive deeply into these elements, or "Elizabeth Holmes 1.0", who was quite decisive and commanding as a public CEO... a far cry from the deer-in-headlights persona she cultivates for the film. We only really see the latter as our framing of reality in the film. A very affecting choice.

@reilly.timhost

“How did your feelings change and how do we reconcile them?”
— @andrewnadkarnihost

sign in to follow your question

topic 3 of 8

Power dynamics, control & relationships

“Is Elizabeth complicit in Billy's abusive behavior toward her? How do we process this in light of a her lifelong history with abusive relationships (Sunny, and her sexual assault while at Stanford)?”
— @reilly.tim

Does Stockholm Syndrome have to present as physical violence? Can it be grooming?

anonymous

sign in to follow your question

sign in to follow your question

topic 5 of 8

Documentary ethics & genre distinctions

“How do we interpret issues of backend profit, editorial control, and informed consent?”
— @andrewnadkarnihost

Do we qualify this as a documentary?

anonymous

“Amanda becomes defensive when Elizabeth says "How could a woman do that to another woman". What does being a woman have to do with how we evaluate Elizabeth's story?”
— @reilly.tim

“I personally don’t think this should be categorized as documentary. I haven’t read Bad Blood but I feel like something based on a piece of investigative journalism would suffice as “documentary” - not a personal PR campaign to make ppl sympathize with her by playing dumb”
— Julie

sign in to follow your question

topic 6 of 8

Narrative construction, setup & payoff

“How do you make sense of recurring images: diving into the water, eye contact, stirring the eggs, turkey jerky, etc?”
— @andrewnadkarnihost

“Do we believe Nathan that he fell in love with Liz a little bit, or is this self-conscious narrative-building?”
— @reilly.timhost

Shine"Woah, heaven let your light shine down."Spotify ↗
the song nathan listens to in the car by himself when Liz and Billy are showering together on departure day
My theater laughed at this part.
My theater laughed at this part.

sign in to follow your question

sign in to follow your question

topic 8 of 8

Media literacy & subjectivity

“Which feels most accurate to put on Nathan's business card for YCSE: documentarian, filmmaker, comedian, performance artist, or investigative journalist?”
— @reilly.timhost

sign in to follow your question

report a problem